Head-to-Head Comparison
| Factor | TaskRabbit | Handy | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hourly Rates | $20-60/hour (you set rates) | $18-45/hour (platform sets) | TaskRabbit |
| Service Fee | 15% platform fee | 20% platform fee | TaskRabbit |
| Job Availability | High in major cities | Consistent nationwide | Handy |
| Job Types | Diverse (assembly, moving, handyman) | Home improvement focused | TaskRabbit |
| Scheduling Flexibility | Complete control over schedule | Some flexibility, batch bookings | TaskRabbit |
| Customer Support | Basic support | More comprehensive support | Handy |
| Geographic Coverage | 50+ major US cities | 100+ US cities + suburbs | Handy |
| Getting Started | Profile + skills verification | Application + background check | TaskRabbit |
T
TaskRabbit Analysis
Marketplace for diverse skilled tasks and services
✅ Strengths
- • Higher Rates: Set your own prices, earn $25-75/hour
- • Job Variety: Furniture assembly, mounting, moving, handyman
- • Schedule Control: Work when you want, accept jobs you choose
- • Lower Fees: 15% service fee vs 20% on other platforms
- • Tips Allowed: Customers can tip for excellent service
❌ Challenges
- • Limited Coverage: Only available in major metropolitan areas
- • Competition: High competition in popular categories
- • Inconsistent Work: Income can vary significantly week to week
- • Customer Interaction: Need to communicate directly with clients
- • Tools Required: Must own and transport your own tools
💡 Success Strategy
Focus on 2-3 high-demand categories like furniture assembly or TV mounting. Build excellent reviews quickly, then gradually raise your rates to premium levels.
H
Handy Analysis
Home improvement and handyman services platform
✅ Strengths
- • Wider Coverage: Available in 100+ cities including suburbs
- • Consistent Work: More predictable booking flow
- • Customer Support: Better platform support for issues
- • Specialization: Focus on home improvement and repair
- • Batch Bookings: Can book multiple jobs in same area
❌ Challenges
- • Fixed Pricing: Platform sets rates, less earning control
- • Higher Fees: 20% service fee reduces take-home pay
- • Strict Requirements: More stringent background checks
- • Limited Job Types: Mainly home improvement tasks
- • Performance Metrics: Must maintain high ratings to stay active
💡 Success Strategy
Maintain excellent ratings and customer service. Work efficiently to maximize jobs per day. Consider specializing in higher-paying services like plumbing or electrical work.
💰 Real Earnings Breakdown
TaskRabbit Weekly Earnings
Part-time (15 hrs):
$400-750
$25-50/hour average
Full-time (40 hrs):
$1,000-2,000
$25-50/hour average
Top Performers:
$2,500+
$50-75/hour in premium markets
Handy Weekly Earnings
Part-time (15 hrs):
$300-600
$20-40/hour average
Full-time (40 hrs):
$800-1,600
$20-40/hour average
Top Performers:
$2,000+
$45-50/hour with high efficiency
Monthly Income Potential
TaskRabbit: $1,600-8,000+/month
Higher rates but less predictable volume
Higher rates but less predictable volume
Handy: $1,200-6,400+/month
Lower rates but more consistent bookings
Lower rates but more consistent bookings
Most Profitable Service Categories
Top TaskRabbit Categories
High-Demand Services
- • Furniture Assembly: $35-65/hour
- • TV Mounting: $40-80/hour
- • Moving Help: $30-55/hour
- • Handyman Tasks: $40-75/hour
Specialized Services
- • Smart Home Setup: $50-100/hour
- • Event Setup: $45-85/hour
- • Organization: $35-60/hour
- • Painting: $40-70/hour
💡 Pro Tip: Bundle related services to increase average job value
Top Handy Categories
Home Improvement
- • General Handyman: $25-45/hour
- • Plumbing Repairs: $35-55/hour
- • Electrical Work: $40-60/hour
- • Carpentry: $30-50/hour
Assembly & Mounting
- • Furniture Assembly: $20-35/hour
- • TV Mounting: $25-40/hour
- • Shelf Installation: $20-35/hour
- • Picture Hanging: $18-30/hour
💡 Pro Tip: Specialize in plumbing or electrical for higher rates
🚀 Getting Started: Requirements & Process
TaskRabbit Requirements:
Basic Requirements
- • Age 18+ with valid ID
- • Social Security number
- • Pass background check
- • Own reliable transportation
- • Basic tools for chosen categories
Application Process:
- Create profile with skills and experience
- Set hourly rates for each service
- Complete skills verification (optional)
- Pass background check (1-2 weeks)
- Start accepting tasks immediately
Handy Requirements:
Basic Requirements
- • Age 18+ with valid ID
- • Social Security number
- • Pass comprehensive background check
- • Own vehicle and tools
- • Minimum 2 years experience preferred
Application Process:
- Submit detailed application
- Phone interview with Handy team
- Complete background check (2-3 weeks)
- Skills assessment and training
- Start receiving job offers
💡 Success Timeline
TaskRabbit: Faster start (1-2 weeks), income ramps up as you build reviews and optimize rates
Handy: Slower start (2-4 weeks), but more consistent bookings once approved